Given the notorious issues fellow Nintendo Switch owners may have experienced with the deadly “JoyCon Drift” defect, common to Nintendo Switch JoyCons, many players, myself included like to use alternative controllers, especially when playing on a TV.
I’ve tried a few different controllers for the Nintendo Switch over the years and a few clear favourites have emerged for me. My main requirement for a good controller is that it has to be wireless.
It amazes me how many third-party controllers I see in Big W and EB Games that are wired. It’s 2025. We don’t need wired controllers anymore! These third parties always try and distract you with a cool and fun design or character artwork, but beyond that novelty, the cord is not worth it.
Overall, two controllers have stood out to me over the years: the PowerA GameCube Controller and the official Switch Pro Controller. Each brings its own unique features and advantages to the table, appealing to different types of players.
PowerA GameCube Wireless Switch Controller
A few improvements over the original GameCube controller (and the original wireless Wavebird model for that console) include a larger D-pad (directional pad) and added motion controls. These were launched originally as the GameCube controller has historically been the preferred controller for fans of the Super Smash Bros series, with Super Smash Bros Ultimate being an early Switch release.
The only drawback of this against the original GameCube controller is that the rubber on the analogue sticks does not feel as soft and rubbery as the originals. This may have been an intentional design choice, however, as the original was not the most durable.
One thing to note is that the PowerA GameCube controller does not appear to be made anymore. the Australian EB Games website does not stock them anymore and there are not many options left on Australian Amazon. Whilst I’ve not tried it myself, there is now a version by HORI, another reputable third-party controller and accessory company. Their version features a rechargeable battery a few extra buttons for turbo functions and also some rubber grips. Both the Hori and PowerA controllers feature the larger D-Pad and have an additional left trigger button (the original Gamecube only had two buttons on the right).
Official Switch Pro Controllers
Conversely, the Switch Pro Controller is Nintendo’s official solution that fully utilises the Switch’s capabilities. It features wireless connectivity, extended battery life, and a conventional design that suits various gaming genres. The button layout is more aligned with current gaming standards, delivering a familiar experience for those accustomed to other consoles. Although it comes at a higher price point, many find its features and flexibility worth the investment.
I believe the Switch Pro Controller to be among the best controllers Nintendo has ever made. There are many third-party controllers (including some by PowerA and HORI) that closely replicate the design of the Pro Controller but with fewer features. In many cases, the price difference isn’t even that much, meaning I’d still suggest saving up a little extra for the Pro Controller.
In conclusion, the choice between the PowerA (or HORI) GameCube Controller and the Switch Pro Controller ultimately boils down to personal preference and gaming style. Nostalgic gamers, especially Super Smash Bros fans may prefer the GameCube Controller, while those seeking modern versatility are likely to opt for the Pro Controller. I find it unlikely that anyone new to the GameCube controller would prefer it over the Pro, however.
